16 Payne Street

Garden City, Winnipeg

70.2

Good

Overall 70.2

Compared with neighbourhood average

1,197 sqft (top 48%)

Built in 1959 (2 yrs older than avg)

Located in a high-income area

with median household income of ~100k

Transit 88.0

2-min walk to transit with 3 nearby routes

Within 500m: 6 dining spots, 1 school, 3 shops, and 4 parks nearby

Living Area

Near average

8% smaller than neighborhood avg.

Year Built

Near average

2 yrs older than neighborhood avg.

Mother tongue

English · 40%Tagalog · 30%

Past 10 years Garden City sales snapshot (~80% of all data)

Sold Count

616

Median price

411k

$/sqft

$361/sqft

Avg build year

1961

Need help understanding this property?

Buying a home is more than a transaction. Our Winnipeg real estate agents provide market insights, pricing analysis, and neighbourhood expertise to help you decide with confidence.

Usually replies in a few minutes

Property score

70.2 is composed by the two sections below.

Property Score

58.8Fair
Living Area1,197 sqft60Fair
Year Built195943Low
Lot Size6,149 sqft81Excellent
Neighbourhood Sales Activity42Low

Community Score

87.2Excellent
Household Income85Excellent
Education Level82Excellent
Housing Stress100Excellent
Core Housing Need100Excellent
Employment Health83Excellent

Neighbourhood Sales

Garden City

How to read: Share of sales in each ~$50k price band for “garden city” (Detached houses (non-condo), 2024). The tallest band is the mainstream budget range; multi-year view shows how that band shifts over time.

Market Conditions · WinnipegSeller's Market
Buyer'sBalancedSeller's

Sales-to-New-Listings

64.6%

1,196

sold

1,852

new listings

Manitoba Real Estate Association March public data on New Listings and Properties Sold across Manitoba

Sold Above Asking

65%

Majority sold above asking

68 of 104 sold above asking · Manually compiled from MLS Winnipeg sold listings, May 4 – May 10, 2026

With a Sales-to-New-Listings ratio of 64.6% and 65% of homes selling above asking price, demand is clearly outpacing supply. Buyers are competing, which is putting upward pressure on prices.

Area census snapshot

Dissemination area (DA) — Statistics Canada 2021 Census · Area: #46110929

Community deep dive

$100K

Median household income

$106K

Average household income

3%

Low income (LIM-AT)

0.2

Income inequality (Gini)

2.4

P90 / P10 ratio

26%

Single-person households

34%

Families with children

Population, labour & age

Population (2021)576
Labour force participation rate73%
Median age40.0
Avg household size3.0
Unemployment rate5%
Population density2057 / km²

Households & income

Low income (LIM-AT, % pop.)3%
Single-person households26%
Couple families with children34%
Median household income (2020)$100K

Housing

Renter households0%
Condominium dwellings0%
Median dwelling value (owners)$300K

Diversity, education & language

Immigrants (share of pop.)63%
Visible minority68%
Bachelor's or higher (25–64)43%
Mother tongue (1st)English · 40%
Mother tongue (2nd)Tagalog · 30%

Figures are for the census dissemination area containing this listing location; sources and margins may apply per Statistics Canada.

Rankings

Living Area

above average
1,197 sqft
0255075100
Same streetTop 6%Same areaTop 48%CitywideBottom 49%
Same street · Payne Street
#1 / 17
Top 6% · Avg 1,090 sqft
Same area · Garden City
#909 / 1,909
Top 48% · Avg 1,307 sqft
Citywide · Winnipeg
#98,696 / 194,458
Bottom 49% · Avg 1,342 sqft

Tax-Assessed Value

around average
331k
0255075100
Same streetBottom 41%Same areaBottom 25%CitywideBottom 39%
Same street · Payne Street
#10 / 17
Bottom 41% · Avg 329.9k
Same area · Garden City
#1,439 / 1,909
Bottom 25% · Avg 357.4k
Citywide · Winnipeg
#117,909 / 194,458
Bottom 39% · Avg 390.1k

Year Built

above average
1959
0255075100
Same streetTop 6%Same areaBottom 41%CitywideBottom 40%

Lot Size

above average
6,149 sqft
0255075100
Same streetTop 18%Same areaTop 38%CitywideTop 28%

To see this property on a map next to nearby houses—and compare year built, living area, assessed value, and lot size in detail—open the neighbourhood analysis page.

Transit & Walkability

Nearby stops, routes & transit score

Nearby Amenities

Dining, education, healthcare, shopping & more

16 Payne Street — 16 amenities found within 500 m, across 6 categories, including 6 dining (nearest 140 m), 1 education (nearest 339 m), 3 shopping (nearest 207 m).

Search radius
🍽️Dining6
🏫Education1
🛒Shopping3
🌳Parks4
🏦Finance1
Fuel Stations1

Crime & Safety

Garden City · WPS public data · 2026

Annual incidents

45

2026

vs. city avg

+53%

relative to avg

Year-over-year

-94%

vs. prior year

Primary type

Property

69%

Sales History

Sold 7/2016CA$250k–300k
Sold price

Same street

Bottom 1%

Same area

Bottom 31%

City-wide

Bottom 37%

Related homes

Highlights & common questions: 16 Payne Street, Winnipeg

Property Overview

16 Payne Street is a well-maintained one-storey home in Winnipeg's Garden City neighbourhood. Built in 1959, it offers 1,197 sqft of living space and sits on a generous 6,149 sqft lot. Key features include a renovated basement and a detached garage. Its assessed value is positioned around the average for its street and the wider city, but is notably below average for the Garden City area itself, which may present a value opportunity.

Section 1: Key Characteristics & Appeal

The primary appeal of this home lies in its balanced combination of space, lot size, and updates. The living area is notably above average for Payne Street, providing more interior room than most immediate neighbours. The renovated basement adds functional, modernized space. The lot size is a significant asset, ranking well above average both on its street and city-wide, offering ample outdoor potential.

This property would suit practical buyers looking for a solid, single-level home in a established neighbourhood. It’s ideal for someone who values a larger yard for gardening, children, or pets, and appreciates having the major update of a finished basement already completed. The detached garage is a plus for hobbyists or those needing extra storage. The data suggests it represents a sensible value proposition within Garden City, potentially offering more house and land for the dollar compared to area averages.

Section 2: Frequently Asked Questions

1. How does the assessed value compare to likely market value?
While the assessed value is around $33.1k, it's crucial to note this is for taxation purposes. Market value is determined by recent sales. The home's last recorded sale was in 2016 for between $27.5k and $30.5k. Current value would be influenced by the renovated basement, the desirable lot size, and broader market conditions.

2. What does the "below average" assessed value for Garden City indicate?
This statistic means this home's tax assessment is lower than about 75% of comparable properties in Garden City. This doesn't necessarily mean the home is inferior; it can sometimes reflect a slower pace of assessment updates relative to market improvements or simply a different valuation approach. It can, however, suggest a potentially attractive entry point into the neighbourhood.

3. Is the 1959 build date a concern?
The home is one of the newer builds on Payne Street. While any home of this age will require ongoing maintenance, its year of construction is actually above average for the immediate area, meaning core components may be relatively younger than those of many neighbours.

4. What are the implications of such a large lot?
A lot size over 6,000 sqft provides valuable outdoor space and future potential. It offers privacy, room for additions like a deck or shed, and is a long-term asset in a city where lot sizes on newer homes are typically smaller. It's important to check municipal bylaws for any plans regarding additions or secondary suites.

5. Where can I find exact historical sale prices?
The provided sale history shows estimated ranges. To obtain the exact sale prices from the available transaction records, you must request them directly via the email prompt on the listing page. The service provides these figures manually at no cost and does not use the request for marketing purposes.

Radar charts, rankings, and side-by-side layouts work best on a larger screen. Open this page on a desktop browser for the full experience.