Property score
58.5
Fair
Overall 58.5 · Smaller and older than most nearby homes
828 sqft (bottom 1%) · Built in 1972 (8 yrs older than avg)
Located in a above-average income area with median household income of ~77.5k
Transit 82.0 · 2-min walk to transit with 2 nearby routes · Within 500m: 1 place of worship nearby
Living Area
Below average
46% smaller than neighborhood avg.
Year Built
Below average
8 yrs older than neighborhood avg.
Mother tongue
English · 85%French · 2%
Past 10 years Elmhurst sales snapshot (~80% of all data)
438
477k
$391/sqft
1980
Buying a home is more than a transaction. Our Winnipeg real estate agents provide market insights, pricing analysis, and neighbourhood expertise to help you decide with confidence.
Usually replies in a few minutes
Free · No credit card required
58.5 is composed by the two sections below.
Property Score
Community Score
Elmhurst
How to read: Share of sales in each ~$50k price band for “elmhurst” (Detached houses (non-condo), 2024). The tallest band is the mainstream budget range; multi-year view shows how that band shifts over time.
Sales-to-New-Listings
1,196
sold
1,852
new listings
Manitoba Real Estate Association March public data on New Listings and Properties Sold across Manitoba
Sold Above Asking
Majority sold above asking
68 of 104 sold above asking · Manually compiled from MLS Winnipeg sold listings, May 4 – May 10, 2026
With a Sales-to-New-Listings ratio of 64.6% and 65% of homes selling above asking price, demand is clearly outpacing supply. Buyers are competing, which is putting upward pressure on prices.
Dissemination area (DA) — Statistics Canada 2021 Census · Area: #46110352
$78K
Median household income
$102K
Average household income
12%
Low income (LIM-AT)
0.3
Income inequality (Gini)
4.6
P90 / P10 ratio
46%
Single-person households
19%
Families with children
Figures are for the census dissemination area containing this listing location; sources and margins may apply per Statistics Canada.
Rank by land area, larger = better rank
Rank by year, newer = better rank
Rank by living area, larger = better rank
Rank by assessed value, higher = better rank
Bar: fill length ≈ share of peers you outperform. Fill color reflects tier (red / blue / amber / gray). “Avg” is a rough median benchmark for comparable homes in that scope.
To see this property on a map next to nearby houses—and compare year built, living area, assessed value, and lot size in detail—open the neighbourhood analysis page.
Nearby stops, routes & transit score
Dining, education, healthcare, shopping & more
558 Cathcart Street — 1 amenities found within 500 m, across 1 categories.
Elmhurst · WPS public data · 2026
Annual incidents
5
2026
vs. city avg
-83%
relative to avg
Year-over-year
▼ -92%
vs. prior year
Primary type
Property
80%
558 Cathcart Street: We are not showing a transaction history based solely on public data; that does not mean no sale ever occurred. You can still request details by email in the “Data notes” section below—we will look it up manually and reply with the most accurate information available.
Request exact sold prices and history by email
Address · Year Built · Living Area
Address · Distance
Address · Tax-Assessed Value
Property Overview
This 1972 bi-level home at 558 Cathcart Street offers a practical and private living arrangement in Winnipeg's Elmhurst neighborhood. Its key appeal lies in the balance between its generous, mature 7,197 sqft lot and its modest, efficiently designed 828 sqft of living space. The home features a finished basement and an attached garage, providing essential amenities. While the interior is compact, the property ranks highly for its lot size, placing it in the top 15% of all Winnipeg properties, which offers significant outdoor potential and a sense of space uncommon for the price point. It suits first-time buyers or downsizers seeking a low-maintenance footprint with a large, usable yard for gardening, recreation, or future expansion. The value proposition is clear: you are investing primarily in land and location within a stable community, with a functional home that serves as a solid foundation.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How does the bi-level layout affect daily living?
The split entry creates defined separation between living and sleeping areas, which can be efficient. However, the stair-centric design means frequent trips up and down, a factor to consider for those with mobility concerns or very young children.
2. The living area seems small. How does the finished basement help?
The finished basement effectively doubles the usable living space, providing crucial room for a family room, home office, or additional bedrooms. It transforms the home from a compact bungalow to a more versatile two-story living environment.
3. The lot is large, but what is the neighborhood like for outdoor living?
Elmhurst is an established area with mature trees and quiet streets. The oversized lot offers exceptional privacy and space for a large deck, play area, or garden, making it feel more secluded than many newer, denser subdivisions.
4. The home is over 50 years old. What should I be mindful of?
While major systems may have been updated, a focus for viewing should be the roof, windows, and foundation typical of the era. The good ranking for assessed value relative to the area suggests the property is well-maintained within its peer group.
5. Who is this property not ideal for?
It may not suit buyers who prioritize a large, open-concept main floor or who do not wish to utilize stairs regularly. Those seeking a brand-new, move-in-ready home with modern finishes might find the scope for personal updates more suited to a hands-on owner.
Radar charts, rankings, and side-by-side layouts work best on a larger screen. Open this page on a desktop browser for the full experience.
